PORTLAND, Ore. — The owners of a building on West Burnside have kept a $1,237,191.92 judgment after the Oregon Court of Appeals upheld a jury verdict against Lamar Obie Company over an exterior wall leased for commercial advertising.
The November 12 ruling affirmed the judgment on a claim for breach of the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing.
The plaintiffs included Jim A. Atwood, individually and as trustee of the Jim A. Atwood Trust, and J.A. Atwood Corporation.
They brought the lawsuit against Lamar Obie Company, a Delaware company, and OnDisplay Advertising. After settling with OnDisplay, they went to trial against Lamar.
The Building Owners Leased the Wall Space for Advertising to Generate Income
According to court documents, the owners used the exterior wall on the west side of the building at 314–316 West Burnside to display commercial advertising for many years.
They leased the wall sign space to advertising companies to generate revenue. The leases ran for set periods, after which the owners could lease the space to another advertiser.
The arrangement at issue included sharing advertising revenue between the owners and the advertising company.
The jury found for the plaintiffs on the implied duty claim. Damages and costs resulted in the $1,237,191.92 judgment.
Lamar Refused to Sell the Permit to the Plaintiffs
In 2012, Oregon designated the portion of West Burnside where the wall sign is located as a state highway. That brought the sign under state permitting requirements for commercial advertising next to a highway, which ODOT implemented for the sign in 2015.
Court documents reveal that the building owners were not notified by OnDisplay, Lamar, or the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) when ODOT issued a permit solely to OnDisplay and later transferred it exclusively to Lamar.
Communicating via counsel, Lamar confirmed that it would not sell the permit to plaintiffs because it would not serve Lamar’s interest to ‘allow a competing advertising agency to saturate the market even further.’
Lamar obtained relocation credit from ODOT, which allows the holder to display advertising in a new location with strict geographic limits. However, there was no location available for Lamar’s relocation credit, according to the opinion.
The owners have not been able to use the wall sign for commercial advertising since July 1, 2019.
Lamar maintained that, as the owner of the ODOT permit, it had no legal duty to give the permit to plaintiffs at the end of the lease period, and that it was authorized by law to seek relocation credit.









Be the first to comment.