The Oregon Court of Appeals has ruled that a claim for breach of an insurance contract’s duty of good faith and fair dealing can qualify for attorney fees, sending a $40,000 fee award back to a Multnomah County judge for reconsideration.
Judgment Reverses Circuit Court’s Attorney-Fee Ruling
In its November 18 ruling in Precy Conry v. Standard Fire Insurance Company, the appeals court reversed and remanded the attorney-fee judgment entered by Multnomah County Circuit Court Judge Celia A. Howes.
Presiding Judge Aoyagi wrote that it is a longstanding common-law principle that contracts impose a duty of good faith and fair dealing in their performance. That includes insurance contracts.
The court referred to Oregon statute ORS 742.061(1), which requires reasonable attorney fees in certain qualifying lawsuits upon insurance policies, including where the plaintiff’s recovery exceeds the insurer’s tender.
The Insurer Failed to Fully Cover Her Medical Expenses After a Car Accident
The plaintiff sued Standard Fire Insurance when it failed to cover her full medical expenses following a car accident in which she was a passenger. She was covered under the driver’s Standard Fire policy.
Standard Fire is part of Travelers Group.
Conry sought $5,015 in damages for breach of contract and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and another $52,000 in damages for negligence per se.
After more than a year of litigation, the parties agreed to settle all three claims for $36,500, exclusive of fees and costs, which they left to the trial court to decide.
Conry requested $162,694.50 in attorney fees, and the trial court awarded her $40,000.
Tidings Data Snapshot
Settlement and Legal Fees in the Conry CaseDifferent amounts for the claims and the fee dispute| Amount | Dollars |
|---|---|
| Claims settlement, excluding fees and costs | $36,500 |
| Attorney fees requested | $162,694.50 |
| Previous attorney-fee award | $40,000 |
The appeal concerns attorney fees, not the settled claims. The trial court must reconsider the fee award; no new amount was ordered.
Source: Oregon Court of Appeals / Conry v. Standard Fire, November 18, 2026DailyTidings.com
Court Orders Attorney-Fee Award to Be Reconsidered
The appeals court ruled that the attorney-fee award should be reconsidered. However, it did not order that the full amount requested be paid or decide whether $40,000 was reasonable.
The court found that the trial court awarded fees only on the breach-of-contract claim, but should also have treated the good-faith-and-fair-dealing claim as eligible for fees.
The parties agreed that the negligence per se claim was not fee-bearing under the statute. The trial court must decide the reasonable fee and how to allocate work among the claims.
‘We therefore reverse and remand for the trial court to reconsider its fee award with a correct understanding of which claims are fee bearing,’ the court wrote.









Be the first to comment.