Commentary by Cynthia Tucker of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
WASHINGTON — If immigrants represented the best and the brightest, we'd eagerly welcome them into the United States, right? If they learned to speak English. If they were strivers and achievers. If they worked hard and reached for the brass ring, we wouldn't deny them the opportunity to join the American mainstream. Would we?
Yes, we would.
Jessica Colotl, 21, is a senior at a suburban Atlanta college, a political science major and a member of Lambda Theta Alpha, a college sorority. She wants to attend law school.
However, she came to this country illegally with her parents when she was a child. And her detractors don't care what she's accomplished since then. They want to send her back to Mexico, a country she barely knows.
Following a routine traffic stop on campus in late March, Colotl was arrested and sent to a federal detention facility to await deportation. After an outcry by friends and support from faculty members, immigration authorities agreed to defer action on her deportation for a year, giving her time to finish her undergraduate degree. Said college president Daniel Papp, "We are especially thrilled she will be allowed to continue her studies here."
But that has infuriated some hard-liners. For them, Colotl's illegal entry is the most salient fact on her resume, her lack of a green card more important than her grade-point average. Her academic achievement, her English skills, her all-American sorority girl status — none of that placates the "WHAT PART OF ILLEGAL DON'T THEY UNDERSTAND?" crowd. As one suburban Atlanta newspaper columnist wrote, "Most citizens don't care how much 'potential' the young lady has."
The uproar, though ugly, accomplishes something important: It brushes away the layers of pretense, polite subterfuge and politically acceptable criticism. The truth is laid bare: We're a recession-weary nation wrestling with a bout of brutal, racially tinged nativism — seeking scapegoats for economic failure, unsettled by demographic upheaval, unable to cope with a flatter world.
The intense backlash against undocumented immigrants — especially those from south of the border — isn't really a reaction to overtaxed public services or rising crime. (In most of the country, including Arizona, crime is down.) Instead, it's a backlash against the dizzying pace of change, against a cultural landscape growing more diverse, against a voting base growing browner with each census.
Arizona's ugly immigration law — which, according to polls, is supported by a majority of Americans — is one sign of the harsh climate toward those without papers. Other signs dot the political landscape: Sen. John McCain's retreat from his earlier embrace of comprehensive immigration reform; the reluctance of a Democratic Congress to wade into the debate before mid-term elections; the eagerness of other states to copy Arizona's brand of apartheid.
Even the nation's Latino Republicans feel the fury of their neighbors' xenophobia. Writing on a conservative website, Robert Gonzalez, a Mexican-American attorney and a Republican, described the discomfort he felt as he overheard campaign volunteers, whom he had enlisted to work in Tucson for George W. Bush, talk about Mexican immigrants:
"Some of the things I heard coming from these volunteers, regarding "the Mexicans," shook me: about how they should be kept out, about how the border fence could not be built high enough, made it seem as if we were the real threat to American society," he wrote.
In Georgia, Colotl's troubles continue. She is in the crosshairs of a local sheriff who says she gave him a fake address (lying to law enforcement authorities is a crime), and of anti-immigration activists who have made her an unlikely symbol of a failed system that, they claim, unfairly subsidizes illegal immigrants. GOP gubernatorial candidate Eric Johnson, meanwhile, has proposed that illegal immigrants be shut out of the state's colleges and universities, a plan that represents an embarrassing step in the wrong direction.
But Johnson's proposal has this virtue: It makes clear that he doesn't care how well undocumented immigrants speak English.
Cynthia Tucker is a political writer for The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and a nationally syndicated columnist. She can be reached at email@example.com.